

2026
Spotify vs. Apple Music
Before I designed anything, I spent a while comparing Spotify and Apple Music side by side, feature by feature. Spotify wins on almost every “smart” feature: Discover Weekly, Daily Mixes, an algorithmic shuffle that actually adapts, AI DJ, all of it. Apple Music’s catalog size is right there with Spotify’s, but the software around it hasn’t caught up. I’m an Apple Music user myself because of the ecosystem and the audio quality, and when I asked around, basically every other Apple Music user I talked to said some version of the same thing: they wished Apple Music felt as smart as Spotify, but didn’t want to actually switch services to get it due to the friction of switching ecosystems.
That pain point was the main premise for Sift. Rather than build another music player, I wanted to build the layer Apple Music should have shipped to be an even more competitive service, on top of the subscription people already have.
What Sift Actually Does
The first thing I tackled was shuffle, because shuffle on Apple Music is really just a random sort, it has no memory of what you skip or replay. I built Smart Control around a single Familiarity dial that goes from deep cuts you barely play to your most-played songs, backed by individual signal weights (skips, recent plays, repeats, minutes listened) so the shuffle actually reflects real listening behavior instead of pure chance. Next to that is Auto-Sort, which takes one big messy playlist and splits it into smaller ones by genre, artist, or vibe in a couple clicks, something that used to be a manual, annoying process.
The feature I’m most proud of is the AI Playlist Generator, because it’s not something Spotify or Apple Music does either. You type a plain description, a mood, an event, an artist combo, and Sift searches all of Apple Music (not just your library) to build a real playlist out of it, and you can keep refining it with follow-up prompts until it’s right. That one feature alone is the reason I’d pick Sift over just opening Apple Music directly as it tackles a major want from music listeners. Anyone can ask an LLM to do the same but to actually have it integrated with plalist fully created and generated for usability in under a minute is something neither Spotify or Apple Music has.




